Wednesday, August 01, 2007

Protes Atas Protes

Ini kenyataan rasmi PKPIM mengenai konsert tersebut:


SIARAN MEDIA 30 JULAI 2007/ 16 REJAB:PKPIM MEMBANTAH PENGANJURAN KONSERT GWEN STEFANI YANG DIJADUALKAN PADA 21 OGOS 2007.

Oleh: Mohd Hilmi Ramli
Presiden Persatuan Kebangsaan Pelajar Islam Malaysia (PKPIM)

Persatuan Kebangsaan Pelajar Islam Malaysia (PKPIM) melahirkan rasa kesal di atas rancangan Syarikat Maxis Telekomunikasi Berhad menganjurkan konsert Gwen Stefani pada 21 Ogos 2007 ini. Penganjuran konsert terbabit jelas menunjukkan yang ia bertentangan dengan budaya dan norma-norma kehidupan masyarakat timur. Kehadiran artis luar ini dikhuatiri akan mempersembahkan persembahan yang melanggar garis panduan yang telah dikeluarkan oleh Suruhanjaya Komunikasi dan Multimedia Malaysia, melihat kepada latar belakang dan sejarah penyanyi berkenaan. Tambahan pula tayangan iklan dan klip video artis tersebut dilihat tidak sesuai dengan budaya masyarakat Malaysia.

Tayangan iklan di televisyen berkenaan konsert sangat melucahkan, memberi kesan yang buruk kepada kanak- kanak. Berdasarkan pemerhatian PKPIM, Syarikat Maxis Telekomunikasi Berhad telah menganjurkan beberapa siri konsert artis luar negara, yang sebenarnya semacam bukan untuk mengangkat martabat industri kesenian negara, akan tetapi mengaut keuntungan dan mendedahkan generasi muda kepada kerosakan moral. PKPIM mempersoalkan sejauh mana sikap ‘corporate social responsibility’ pihak Maxis? Apakah niat sebenar Maxis menganjurkan konsert yang marathon sifatnya itu. Bukankah lebih baik Maxis menaja and membantu pendidikan pelajar miskin di kawasan pendalaman dan kampung- kampung? Kebanyakkan konsert yang dianjurkan menampilkan artis yang tidak senonoh, seperti Pussy Cat Dolls.

Mengikut kod 15.2 daripada suruhanjaya tersebut menyatakan pemakaian artis wanita yang ingin membuat persembahan di Malaysia adalah seperti berikut: i) pakaian hendaklah lengkap, kemas sopan dan tidak terlalu ketat ;ii)pakaian hendaklah tidak mendedahkan sebahagian besar dada dan perut iii) skirt hendaklah di bawah paras lutut; dan iv) kain berbelah (slit) sama ada di hadapan, di tepi atau di belakang hendaklah tidak melebih dua (2) inci di atas paras lutut.


Selain itu, kod 15.3 menyatakan bahawa Artis Lelaki dan Wanita perlu mematuhi garis panduan seperti di bawah: i) muka hendaklah tidak diconteng; ii) pakaian hendaklah tidak koyak atau bertampal-tampal; iii) pakaian hendaklah tidak terlalu jarang atau yang memberikan kesan jarang; iv) pakaian hendaklah tidak memaparkan simbol, perkataan sumbang atau gambar lucah; v) jenis-jenis pakaian hendaklah tidak mnembayangkan pemakainya tidak berpakaian; vi) baju hendaklah berlengan kecuali semasa berpakaian tradisional; vii) tatu hendaklah tidak dipamerkan pada mana-mana bahagian tubuh badan kecuali sememangnya menjadi unsur budaya seseorang artis itu; dan viii) perwatakan hendaklah tidak berlawanan dengan jantina sebenar kecuali dengan kebenaran

Berdasarkan kod etika di atas, sememangnya artis yang bakal dijemput sudah melanggar kod etika tersebut. Bukan setakat kod tersebut, bahkan dari segi adab dan budaya pun sudah bertentangan. PKPIM melihat sudah ada kecenderungan di beberapa pihak seperti syarikat telekomunikasi yang berlumba-lumba mengadakan konsert di mana kebanyakan artisnya adalah artis luar negara yang jelas tidak mengetahui dan memahami kebudayaan masyarakat Malaysia. Trend ikutan budaya Barat terutama dari segi pemakaian semakin menjadi-jadi di Malaysia. Perkara ini bertambah buruk apabila ada pihak yang seakan-akan mengizinkan perkara ini berlaku.

Gejala hendonisme iaitu hiburan yang melampau-lampau semakin hari semakin menghakis daya intelektual dan budaya masyarakat Malaysia. Penganjuran konsert terbabit boleh menggalakkan lagi budaya yang tidak sihat ini. Sedangkan seperti yang kita maklum, budaya timur yang menghiasi masyarakat kita sejak turun temurun dari generasi ke generasi begitu kaya dengan amalan budi bahasa, sikap sopan santun, berpekerti mulia yang jelas bercanggah dengan budaya barat ini. PKPIM bertegas agar pihak pengurusan konsert terbabit, iaitu Maxis segera membatalkan persembahan artis Gwen Stefani pada 21 Ogos 2007 ini. Janganlah tunggu sehingga Maxis dicop sebagai agen perosak bangsa nanti!

MOHD HILMI RAMLI
Presiden
Persatuan Kebangsaan Pelajar Islam Malaysia (PKPIM)


Berikut adalah respon 'ekstrimis' yang diterima dalam emel. 'Beliau' menghantar emel protes atas protes.:


To whom it may concern,

I took this excerpt from a source that I am not able to disclose, but I
share this person's sentiments;

"What exactly, is all the fussing about right now? Gwen Stefani coming for a
concert? Moral decay to today's local youth? Look around you, (sic) look at
Malaysia before making us look like idiots. Look at the local tabloids, look
at *Mangga, Hai, *and the likes of those magazines. Look at the half naked
muslim women baring their thighs, their cleavage, posing in the water for
every man's masturbatory fantasy? Look at FHM, when Hani was on the cover
posing in her corset and high heel shoes? Look at youtube, look at the
muslim girls in their tudungs fucking in the car, in the bushes, giving
blowjobs under their man's sarong?

How can they say Gwen Stefani, or any other actor morally decays a teenager
and they want to try so hard to stop a concert... but that artist is playing
on every tv, every radio station, on every magazine, website, table top?
Stopping a concert won't decay another youth's mind- it's 2007, we have more
then just concerts to decay our minds. There's always the internet, there's
our parents, there's the people around us.

You cannot stop moral decay by stopping one concert. You should just switch
off all the lights in Malaysia and proceed to let us live in darkness...
maybe then the *decay *would stop?"

20 comments:

Mohd Nadmin said...

Susah memang susah..sekarang ni dah macam-macam jenis media yang merosakkan..tapi bila bercakap soal media, memang susah la..kita cuba untuk menghalang salah satu daripada perkara yang merosakkan moral..apa salahnya?..org yg mengkritik mungkin tak memandang masa depan..mahukah mereka melihat negara kita seperti Amerika?..seks bebas di kalangan remaja..

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

kami berjuang mana yang mampu...anda? apa yang anda buat?..sekadar fucking je yang anda pandai sebut?..apa kata anda pun cuba berbuat sesuatu..jgn asying nak fucking dan mengata org je..kalo anda mampu untuk memperjuangkan sesuatu, perjuangkanlah...apa kata anda sendiri yang bertanya soalan itu kpd khairy jamaludin?..dan bertindaklah..lakukan sesuatu utk kebaikan kita bersama

Anonymous said...

well do u think just by banning gwen from coming here is going to solve your problems?

i wonder where all your mat rempits and bohsias learn about sex? have you seen all your awek bertudungs fucking around without watching TV? where the hell did they learn how to fuck?

you guys are stupid. I go to Saudi Arabia every week. and you know what I found? There are a huge community of HOMOs! do you know what a homosexual is? tahu tak apa itu Gay?

since you are a muslim u should know what rules and regulations saudi arabia has. these rules had created a bunch of gay boys fucking each other's backsides. do you like it from the back?

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
TajamFikir said...

(to whom it may concern: all comment to article"protes atas protes" were rubbish except one fronm nadmin and another from anonymous (12:23pm)).well of course by banning one gweni practically couldnt stop all prob but nature konsert beliau tetap suatu masalah dan pasti menyumbang kepada gejala keruntuhan moral.sudah tentu antara yang memainkan peranan di dalam menggalakkan anak2 muda untuk melepaskan nafsu dgn cara haram adalah melaui penampilan gwen itu sendiri ketika melakukan konsert.. at least arab saudi ada undang2 terhadap perkara berkenaan,jumlah homo di sana sudah tentu amat kecil dibandingkan di barat..Betul, kebanyakkan orang melayu kampung mungkin tidak mahir berbahasa inggeris ataupun lemah daripada segi penguasaan mereka di dalam bahasa mereka, but itu x bermakna mereka akan terlepas daripada pengaruh negatif gwen.. kerana pengaruh lirik nya amat kecil dibandingkan dengan pengaruh penampilan, pakaian, cara menari, sikap dan lain-lain yang banyak dilihat melalui mata.Improve comments la..mcm budak2 komenye, kpd anonymous 1:26am ko mesti ada bad relationship dgn mak ko kan, tu pasallah ko sanggup rendahkan martabat seorang mak untuk melakukan sesuatu yang keji... makna serta tasawwur pandangan hidup korang ni kosong, mcm tin kosong.. bicaranya berkokok tapi bila dibaca ternyata hampas....

Akhie Naim said...

Looking through the comments posted here, I cannot help but wonder what is happening to the quality of thought and moral of our youth in Malaysia. To all the "Anonymous" writers, please prove to us that you're matured people. You guys are using very dirty and obscene words -- proof of what we are saying about the moral decay of our youth today. Are you guys really concerned about the future of our country, or even our world for that matter?

True enough, there are lots of factors that contribute towards the moral decay and even the 'incapacitating' process of the minds of our youth today. But, is that enough reason for us to do nothing? We may not be able to tackle all the issues, what more with having ignorant youth who support all these indecent and hedonistic culture making our task even harder. But at least we are trying to do something - as a start - to try to put a stop to the growing hedonistic culture. Ask yourself, are you just helping the unhealthy culture to grow, or are you doing something to help develop better youth for our future?

suhail said...

congratulation PKPIM esp our Mr. President for a great spark to the people out there.. i believe PKPIM always stand on a concrete reasoning for every step taken.

the Anonymous attempt to demolish our spirit of bringing back the true way of life would never succeed. The way he speaks reflects his own identity.

Sorry anonymous, you have mistuned your thought.. every issues stated by you are different from each other.

PKPIM, Mr Hilmi.. be proud of the responses given against you. It shows that your idea or protest is heard from people all over the world.

The Islamophobia syndrome is getting worse now.. no matter whatever Muslim say or do, 'these' people would always put it as negative to the world..

'Badaal Islamu ghuraba wa saya'udu ghuraba kama badaa'

Anonymous said...

dear anonymous who gave those four comments,
i would like to ask u to read back what u had written.what do u think?well i think most of the reader surely know what am i going to say.we can clearly see ur own attitude.i don't have to mention it, right? all the words u are using etc.be a matured man.act professionally. there are always a room for u to express ur opinions.so why not u express ur discontentment in a good manner.why must u "scream" or "shout" like an uncivilized people.i don't want to label u as "kurang ajar" because i'm very sure that ur parents had done their responsibility perfectly. i'm sorry if i were wrong. see...the way u act actually can reflect ur family background..the word n msg u want to convey..is really awful..don't u feel ashamed?at least to ur own family...talking all the nonsense.

back to gwen stefani, we can see at the advertisement in hotlink web page.u can see by urself anonymous.let say ur daughter o perhaps ur wife wearing like that(showing part of the body,wearing tight attire like wearing nothing) n singing on the stage while all the people watching, staring n perhaps "think dirty" about it. how u feel?that is in the advertisement.not yet the real person.don't tell me that u r proud of it.of course, as an ordinary people,we will feel angry.by organizing such concert without consider back our culture,our youth or children will be the victims of this problem.i believe such concert will influence our child n youth.
the banning is not about whether extremist or not.but the main issue is the culture that the west brought in and our own culture in asia. we have a different culture.y must we accept those "unhealthy" culture.yes,some good culture maybe can accepted.there is no doubt bout it.am i rite?so do u think such concert with their own "special" culture is a good one n can be accepted?
another one,regarding to the comment on "poor command on english". well maybe u r out dated.now, especially those malay living in the town have a good command of english. there r taught in english since there r young. so for a secondary school student and colleges, there sure will understand the song.so before u comment anything, please make some research. don't fool urself..
i'm sorry for any wrong intepretation.but the most important act like a professional people with a rational mind.

Bob said...

Untuk saudara presiden, tahniah di atas usaha ini. yang penting keredhaan dari illahi. Nak harapkan redha manusia....sampai bila mereka tidak akan puas hati.

insan_unknown said...

CORRECTION!!!!!!
I AM NOT THE ANONYMOUS THAT WROTE ALL THE 4 COMMENTS. I AM NOW insan_unknown.THE COMMENT I WROTE IS THE UP ONE WITH THE SAME COMMENT AS THIS ONE.



dear anonymous who gave those four comments,
i would like to ask u to read back what u had written.what do u think?well i think most of the reader surely know what am i going to say.we can clearly see ur own attitude.i don't have to mention it, right? all the words u are using etc.be a matured man.act professionally. there are always a room for u to express ur opinions.so why not u express ur discontentment in a good manner.why must u "scream" or "shout" like an uncivilized people.i don't want to label u as "kurang ajar" because i'm very sure that ur parents had done their responsibility perfectly. i'm sorry if i were wrong. see...the way u act actually can reflect ur family background..the word n msg u want to convey..is really awful..don't u feel ashamed?at least to ur own family...talking all the nonsense.

back to gwen stefani, we can see at the advertisement in hotlink web page.u can see by urself anonymous.let say ur daughter o perhaps ur wife wearing like that(showing part of the body,wearing tight attire like wearing nothing) n singing on the stage while all the people watching, staring n perhaps "think dirty" about it. how u feel?that is in the advertisement.not yet the real person.don't tell me that u r proud of it.of course, as an ordinary people,we will feel angry.by organizing such concert without consider back our culture,our youth or children will be the victims of this problem.i believe such concert will influence our child n youth.
the banning is not about whether extremist or not.but the main issue is the culture that the west brought in and our own culture in asia. we have a different culture.y must we accept those "unhealthy" culture.yes,some good culture maybe can accepted.there is no doubt bout it.am i rite?so do u think such concert with their own "special" culture is a good one n can be accepted?
another one,regarding to the comment on "poor command on english". well maybe u r out dated.now, especially those malay living in the town have a good command of english. there r taught in english since there r young. so for a secondary school student and colleges, there sure will understand the song.so before u comment anything, please make some research. don't fool urself..
i'm sorry for any wrong intepretation.but the most important act like a professional people with a rational mind.

anti_extremist said...

Alright. Now we are talking. Since we have obtained the various parties attention to this Anonymous postings lets talk facts and objectivity. Can any one of you answer these:

1. Is Gwen Stefani or any other artists performing here a much bigger issue than what we are facing while we 'celebrate' our 50th Anniversary of Independence where each and every single one of the BN politicians are corrupt to the bone and trickled all the way down to individual civil servants?

2. Is the case of Baginda Razak, a prominent MUSLIM political advisor to NAJIB RAZAK (which incidentally declared Malaysia a MUSLIM STATE) and his 2 MUSLIM policemen who blew up a woman he was having an illicit affair with not important to Protest about? Perhaps they have watched too many Arnold Schwazenager movies and learnt how to blow up people?

3. Isn't it more important to go down to the Mat Rempits and Bohsias to try to change their ways instead of killing victims during snatching of their handbags? Why aren't you protesting to the government about rehabilitating these MUSLIM people?

4. Isn't corruption a MAJOR SIN in Islam? What has PKPIM done about this? This means that every MUSLIM traffic police will go to neraka. Why don't PKPIM protest about the traffic police whom have received a substantial pay rise but is still corrupt?

5. Every single UMNO crony and lobbyists are MUSLIMS. And all of them are stealing billions of ringgit in the rakyat's money. I see you don't have the time to highlight this issue that concerns the livelihood of 27 million Malaysians

6. Majority of the RAPE Cases and Incest cases are related to MUSLIM Malays and in come cases IMAMS and BOMOH melayu. Why don't you correct these people before trying correct artists?

I can name 1000 things that are wrong with this country that are directly caused and related to so-called Muslims who fight for Muslim rights and who want to make Malaysia a Muslim state... all for the benefit of their greedy self, which is yet another bad Muslim trait which will give you an automatic pass to go to hell.

By the way, I am not a deranged teen who wants to watch Gwen. I can't be bothered with her although some of her songs are pretty good. I work and live in Dubai, United Arab Emirates and I spend months in Saudi Arabia as a consultant. Saudi Arabia, home of Mecca and Madinah has the following:

1. many homosexuals, drug users and youngsters with nothing to do
2. incest is rife, which results in babies born with Down Syndrome due to the closeness of the gene pool between brothers and sisters
3. extremely rude people who drive like mad men in both Riyadh and Jeddah
4. islamist extremist who wants to take other people to hell so they can be martyred
5. extremely lazy locals because they have been spoon fed by the government (sounds familiar to all bumis?)

I know.... by nature no religion teaches you bad things. Unfortunately for you, the Islamic religion has been twisted and destroyed by your so-called imams and hajis to a point of no return. Take a look at Pakistan, Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Malaysia, Indonesia. All have the same trait... you have greedy religious leaders that will do anything to destroy everything.

anwarshazali said...

look at the despicable rascals. writing as such remembering me of the crazy man with no outwears running along the street and shouting and cursing anybody who look at him. I do think maybe they are in the same group.

maybe I mean just maybe those rascals really like if their mother of sister or even their wife or their illegal mate to wear outfit as Gwen. Why.... isn't that cute looking at those rascals walking along with their imposter of Gwen and of course they feel proud of that. because they want to share their sister, mother, wife with others to see and to touch. isnt that right you despicable rascals.

where do you learn such morals? have you even tought to wear nice by your parents? or that is your parents teach you to go outside and it is ok for you to be half naked...

tajamfikir said...

to anti extrimist: your main concern is, why PKPIM didnt raised the vital issue and why PKPIM only concerned on the "simplistic" issue (according to your thought) well to me both issues raised by you were pivotal issues. It is known that in order to build uncorrupted mind especially our youngsters, there is no doubt that we should emphasized on building good character(akhlaq,adab, sahsiah)why people become addicted to do corruption,bribery or abuse of power,one of the cardinal factor is their "rendah moral" and at the same time gwen stefani based on her performance record, she promote extreme hedonism in her performance( berpakaian tidak senonoh, melingguk-lingguk lain-lain)kalo generasi muda kita sudah didedahkan dgn budaya hedonism melampau ini sudah tentu "will" mereka untuk menjadi seorang warganegara yang baik akan terjejas. yup isu2 lain yang ditimbulkan penting untuk diberikan perhatian. i think we are fighting the same course(iaitu sebarang kefasadan dan kerusakan yg berlaku yang akan menjejaskan manusia as u had raised the issue of altantuya, corruption, rape,incest and others.and of course to me extreme hedonism also belongs to this group.... u mention about Razak Baginda and the other two accused person, could you quarantee they are good muslims?

anti_extremist said...

tajamfikir,

dude.....if Razak Baginda a political advisor that helps the government (our DPM) chart the political landscape of the entire country and the two accused who are high ranking police officers that are assigned to SERVE and PROTECT the people and country are not regarded as GOOD PEOPLE, let alone GOOD MUSLIMS don't you think we are in a teeny weeny bit of TROUBLE as a country????????

I'm still waiting for Hilmi to answer my questions. shouldn't his focus be on the much bigger picture especially when the General Elections are looming and will be called within the next few months? shouldn't your muslim bretherens do something that will affect us for the NEXT 5 years instead of focussing on a single concert for a day on August 21st that may only affect 9,000 people if they are so easily brainwashed as opposed to 27.5 million people that has no choice but to live with the same pathetic government?

or did i put too high of a hope on PKPIM??? perhaps it is run as a very immature organization that is only capable of bringing up ridiculous issues that can make headlines across the rest of the world but have no impact whatsoever in Malaysia?

wadah said...

teruskan perjuangan!jangan semua cacian tu semua!salute kalau konsert akan dibatalkan kelak.

munawwarah said...

assalamualaikum

pendapat saya, kepada commentators yang suka hentam2 usaha baik ni...jgn kita balas dgn kata2 memperlekeh atau menjatuhkan mereka.saya pertama kali melawat blog ini dan tanggapan saya seolah2 masing2 asyik menyalahkan satu sama lain. dalam perjuangan sebenar, matlamat harus jelas. rintangan yg u all dapat mcm perkataan2 yang x best tu...x perlu dibalas dgn perkataan2 yang boleh menyebabkan mereka rasa seolah2 u all pun cepat melatah sama.

tajamfikir said...

dear my friend anti extrimist...the case of razak baginda and the other two accused person is still in the trial, so let the judge who posses legal knowledge and legal mind reach his decision, whether these 3 accused person will be regarded as good people in the eye of law or not.. am i right?

anti_extremist said...

tajamfikir,

if u actually follow the trial, you would know that there is no doubt that Razak Baginda had an intimate relationship with Altantuya and these 2 policemen definitely were involved in her murder. even if they did not kill her, Razak Baginda had already commited khalwat and maksiat and what not... NO? do we need the trial to be complete before we know that?

what about the other cases? Jasin MP, Khairy, Mat Taib, Samy Vellu etc...

tajamfikir said...

Following trial doesnt mean that these 3 accused person would be judged guilty by ur lay mind understanding of law...It is only a perception i thought..
keh keh anti extrimist2 now u recognized khalwat and maksiat as bad things in humanlife..rite? what more on Muslim...